Think about the companies you'd expect to still be growing in 20 years. Chances are they work on problems that get bigger every year: a warming climate, scarce water, aging populations, diseases without a cure. Those problems don't go out of fashion. The companies solving them sell into demand that grows as the problem grows.
Now think about the companies you trust. They pay their people fairly and don't cut corners. Over time, that tends to earn them loyal customers and staff who stay.
Put the two together and impact investing starts to look like common sense. The data agrees. Impact portfolios beat the global stock market in most of the scenarios Schroders and Oxford Saïd Business School tested. The Corporate Knights Clean200 has outrun the MSCI ACWI since 2016. And sustainable funds have outpaced traditional funds since 2018, though they've had bad stretches too.
The four sources don't measure the same thing. Schroders tested impact companies directly. The Clean200 picks companies by what they sell. Morgan Stanley covers every fund with a sustainable label, and the GIIN asked investors how they did against their own targets. We'll take them one at a time, starting with the strongest. If you're new to the topic, Ziggma's guide to impact investing covers the basics.
Schroders and Oxford Saïd Business School found that impact portfolios beat the global stock market in most of the scenarios they tested. The researchers started with 257 listed companies that create positive impact. They built 10 random portfolios of 40 stocks each from that group. Eight of the 10 portfolios outperformed a survivorship-adjusted MSCI ACWI IMI between 2010 and 2023.
Survivorship bias is the flattering effect of testing only companies that still exist today. Companies that went bankrupt, were delisted or were taken over drop out of the sample. A backtest built from today's survivors therefore looks better than what an investor would have earned at the time. The Schroders portfolios were built from impact companies that exist today, so they carry this bias. To make the comparison fair, Schroders measured them against an MSCI ACWI IMI survivors index, which includes only the companies that stayed in the index from 2010 onward.
The Schroders study is the only source in this article that tests impact companies directly. It's also a backtest. The portfolios were built after the fact, and past results don't guarantee future returns.
The Corporate Knights Clean200 returned 282.9% between its launch on July 1, 2016 and January 26, 2026. The MSCI ACWI returned 221.3% over the same period. The MSCI ACWI/Energy Index of fossil fuel companies returned 111.0%.
| Clean200 edition | Clean200 | MSCI ACWI | MSCI ACWI/Energy |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2021 (to Jan 31, 2021) | 113.4% | 78.7% | -13.8% |
| 2022 (to Jan 31, 2022) | 107.1% | 103.2% | 31.7% |
| 2023 (to Jan 31, 2023) | 91.2% | 87.8% | 61.3% |
| 2024 (to Jan 15, 2024) | 103.5% | 114.4% | 64.5% |
| 2025 (to Jan 29, 2025) | 190.9% | 162.0% | 76.7% |
| 2026 (to Jan 26, 2026) | 282.9% | 221.3% | 111.0% |
Corporate Knights and As You Sow publish the Clean200 every year. The 2026 edition chose 200 public companies out of 8,229, ranked by sustainable revenue. Clean200 companies earn an average of 53.7% of their revenue from sustainable activities. Companies in the MSCI ACWI earn 16.7%.
The Clean200 measures what companies sell. It doesn't score labor practices, governance or controversies. A full impact assessment covers those too. Ziggma's best climate stocks list applies both lenses.
Morgan Stanley's data widens the lens from impact companies to every fund labeled sustainable. Impact funds are one part of that group, alongside ESG funds and sustainability-themed funds. Sustainable funds have beaten traditional funds over the long run, but they haven't won every period. The Morgan Stanley Institute for Sustainable Investing compares both groups every six months in its Sustainable Reality report, using Morningstar data.
Morgan Stanley applies median fund returns to a hypothetical $100 invested in December 2018. By mid-2026, that $100 grew to $171 in sustainable funds and $159 in traditional funds.
| Date | Sustainable funds | Traditional funds |
|---|---|---|
| Dec 2018 | $100.0 | $100.0 |
| Dec 2019 | $117.5 | $114.8 |
| Dec 2020 | $135.9 | $131.4 |
| Dec 2021 | $146.5 | $139.4 |
| Jun 2022 | $117.2 | $117.9 |
| Dec 2022 | $119.3 | $118.4 |
| Dec 2023 | $134.1 | $128.8 |
| Dec 2024 | $137.0 | $132.5 |
| Dec 2025 | $162.4 | $152.7 |
| Jun 2026 | $170.4 | $158.8 |
ESG criteria measure risks to a company, not its effect on the world. So the Morgan Stanley data is weaker evidence about impact investing itself. What it shows is that the broader sustainable label hasn't cost investors returns.
Nine in 10 impact investors met or exceeded their financial expectations, according to the Global Impact Investing Network's State of the Market 2025 report. The survey also found that 88% met or exceeded their impact goals. The GIIN surveyed 429 organizations in 54 countries.
Among 79 investors who answered both the 2019 and 2025 surveys, impact assets grew 21% a year over six years. Their total assets grew 5% a year.
The GIIN results come with two limits. Investors measured returns against their own expectations, not against a market benchmark. And most respondents invest directly in private companies, projects and real assets, so the survey says little about public stocks. Ziggma explains how impact works in listed markets in its guide to public market impact investing.
Sustainable funds lagged traditional funds in the second half of 2024 and the second half of 2025, according to Morgan Stanley. In 2024, only 42% of US sustainable funds finished in the top half of their Morningstar category. Morningstar cited high interest rates, which hurt clean energy stocks and other growth companies.
Those setbacks were short-term. Over longer horizons, the evidence points to outperformance. Sustainable funds turned $100 into $171 between December 2018 and mid-2026, vs. $159 for traditional funds. The Clean200 beat the MSCI ACWI by 61.6% over nearly a decade. And 8 of 10 Schroders impact portfolios outperformed over the 14 years between 2010 and 2023.
Impact companies outperformed in the Schroders and Oxford Saïd study because they run differently from the average listed company. The researchers compared the financial profiles of 257 impact companies against traditional benchmarks. They controlled for size, value, momentum, profitability and investment, the standard factors that explain most stock returns. The impact portfolios still showed statistically significant alpha. Schroders traces that alpha to six characteristics.
The more of a company's revenue comes from products with positive impact, the stronger its financial performance tended to be. Schroders calls this impact materiality. A company leading the low-carbon transition or expanding financial inclusion scores high on it. A company with a small green side business scores low. This is the study's central finding: impact pays when it's the business itself, not a side project.
Impact companies earned higher operating margins than their benchmarks. They kept more profit from each dollar of revenue before interest and taxes. Schroders reads this as a sign of stronger business fundamentals. Higher margins also leave more room to absorb cost shocks and fund growth.
Impact companies grew their headcount faster. Schroders links this to active expansion. Companies hire ahead of demand when they expect their markets to grow, and the markets these companies serve, such as clean energy, healthcare and financial inclusion, have been growing.
Impact companies held less cash relative to their total assets. They also raised equity and debt more often than their benchmarks. Schroders attributes both patterns to a growth orientation. These companies reinvest capital in expansion instead of leaving it idle on the balance sheet.
A larger share of impact companies' assets was tangible, such as plants, equipment and infrastructure. Schroders ties this to their sectors, including renewable energy and infrastructure, and to early-stage growth. Younger companies have usually made fewer acquisitions, so less of their balance sheet is goodwill.
Investors paid more for impact companies. They traded at lower earnings-to-price and free-cash-flow-to-price ratios, which means higher price-to-earnings multiples. Schroders notes this matches the profile of high-growth companies. Higher multiples also carry risk: when interest rates rise, growth stocks tend to fall further, as they did in 2024.
The outperformance didn't come from taking more risk. Schroders found that the impact portfolios had lower volatility, smaller drawdowns and milder negative skewness than conventional indices. Put simply, their losses were smaller and less extreme.
Those traits describe efficient, growing businesses. Not every impact company has them. Screening for financial quality separates the ones that do from the ones that don't.
Impact investing is an overlooked source of alpha for self-directed investors. In the strongest study available, Schroders and Oxford Saïd Business School found that 8 of 10 random impact portfolios beat the MSCI ACWI IMI between 2010 and 2023. The Corporate Knights Clean200 beat the MSCI ACWI by 61.6% between July 2016 and January 2026. The assumption that impact costs returns doesn't survive that record.
The drivers of that outperformance are basic business sense. Companies with higher operating margins keep more of every dollar they earn. Companies that put their cash to work grow faster than companies that sit on it. Companies that keep hiring are expanding to meet demand. And companies working on decarbonization, water and healthcare sell into needs that won't go away.
Impact investors don't have to trade returns for their values. They have to own the right companies, which means screening for impact and financial quality together.
Start with what you already own. Ziggma's Impact X-Ray scores every holding across your linked brokerage accounts on Climate Action, Resource Use, Fair Labor and Accountability.
Then add a quality filter. The Ziggma Stock Score rates companies 0–100 on growth, valuation, profitability and financial health. Screening on both the Impact Score and the Ziggma Stock Score removes impact companies with weak fundamentals.
Ziggma's impact model portfolios use this approach. Better Future owns companies with strong Ziggma Stock Scores and strong Impact Scores. Climate Opportunity and Solutions targets companies building the technology and infrastructure for a low-carbon economy. Growth, Impact, Momentum adds a price momentum filter. For individual ideas, see Ziggma's best sustainable stocks.
See how your portfolio scores on real-world impact →